Skip to content

San Francisco

Best Dessert Spots for a Date in Hayes Valley in San Francisco

Ten dessert dates around Hayes Valley, from Sicilian-style gelato and tea-room scones to hazelnut soft serve and Gâteau Victoire.

Hayes Valley has plenty of sweet spots for a casual dessert date, whether you're grabbing gelato, trying matcha soft serve or sharing pastries over tea. From cozy bakeries and charming tea rooms to restaurants with dessert menus worth exploring, these ten spots offer an easy alternative to the usual dinner or drinks date.

10 places

Hila Gelato Caffè

Photo of Hila Gelato Caffè
Photo courtesy of Hila Gelato Caffè

Hila Gelato Caffè is a Valencia Street gelato and coffee shop in the Mission, run as a relaxed gathering place for the neighborhood. The gelato follows Sicilian recipes, and the shop runs on solar power. Fruit and nut gelatos are good ones to share, and an affogato is another option. Hila also teaches gelato-making classes, which could make a hands-on date.

Garden Creamery

For an ice cream date in the Mission, Garden Creamery serves creative, seasonal flavors from its bright red corner shop. The rotating selection often includes Asian and tropical-inspired scoops like ube, lychee black tea and salty kaya, made with organic, grass-fed dairy from Petaluma family farms. Seating is limited to a few small tables and stools, so grab your cones and take a walk toward Dolores Park. Expect a line, especially on weekends. The shop opens at 6 PM midweek, making it a great stop for an evening dessert date.

Lovejoy's Tea Room

For a charming afternoon tea date in Noe Valley, Lovejoy's Tea Room brings a little English cottage atmosphere to San Francisco. Open since the early 1990s, the cozy parlor is filled with Union Jacks, mismatched furniture and vintage china, plus a collection of felted crowns you can try on together. Settle in over bottomless pots of tea, accompanied by scones, tea sandwiches, seasonal dishes and sweets. It's a lovely spot for a leisurely date with plenty of time for conversation.

$

Oishii Matcha

Oishii Matcha is a small matcha cafe in the Castro, selling matcha soft serve and drinks. Outdoor tables overlook Market Street, which makes it a casual stop for coffee and a light bite when you're already nearby, rather than a destination. The soft serve has a strong matcha flavor but can arrive slightly melted, so we'd lean toward a drink such as the matcha strawberry latte.

Hayes Valley / $$$

Absinthe Brasserie & Bar

Photo of Absinthe Brasserie & Bar
Photo courtesy of Absinthe Brasserie & Bar

Absinthe has been a Hayes Valley brasserie since 1998, with lively, informal rooms styled after turn-of-the-century France. Dim lighting and white tablecloths set the mood, and the bar is a natural place to start with classic cocktails. The French Quarter Revival mixes gin, rye, vermouth and bitters, while Death in the Afternoon pairs sparkling wine with absinthe verte. Heading to SFJAZZ, the ballet, the symphony or the opera? Stop here first.

Hayes Valley / $$

Zuni Café

Zuni Café

For a dessert date with a little Parisian charm, Zuni Café has been a San Francisco favorite on Market Street since 1979. The two-story restaurant features large windows, rotating art displays and a copper bar, with regular live piano music adding to the atmosphere. The seasonal menu changes daily, but desserts like Gâteau Victoire and espresso granita are highlights. If you're making a full dinner of it, the signature roast chicken for two takes about an hour to prepare, giving you plenty of time to enjoy a drink together.

What to order
Roast chicken for two with warm bread salad

Hayes Valley / $$

Loquat

LOQUAT

For a pastry date in Hayes Valley, Loquat brings Jewish and Levantine-inspired baked goods to its cozy Gough Street cafe. The salted chocolate babka is perfect for sharing, with thin, golden layers that pull apart easily. Savory options include flaky bourekas filled with warm ricotta and sage. With limited seating, mostly small tables for two, it's a great spot for a casual breakfast date or coffee and a sweet treat. Mornings can get busy, so arrive early to beat the line.

What to order
Kubaneh

$

Mercury Cafe

Photo of Mercury Cafe
Photo courtesy of Mercury Cafe

Mercury Cafe is a bright, unpretentious coffee shop on Octavia Street. It's a throwback that doesn't look like a design store, and the scones are the reason to go, though the coffee is fine and the staff is friendly. Scones sell out, so show up first thing in the morning to grab one to share over coffee.

Ernest

A wall of miniature maneki neko cats greets you at Ernest, a Mission spot with an open kitchen and two levels. The mood is relaxed and fun, and the dining room feels like a supper club, which makes it a fit for date night. Save room for dessert: soft serve in hazelnut and vanilla. The vanilla soft serve has a dense, creamy texture and a gentle sweetness. On weeknights, walk-ups can sit at the bar for oysters and natural wine.

$$$$

Octavia

Photo of Octavia
Photo courtesy of Octavia

Octavia is a neighborhood restaurant in Lower Pacific Heights, with a tree wrapped in white twinkle lights at the entrance. The menu follows the seasons with produce from local farms, and it changes daily with the farmers market. Pasta is the standout, such as spaghetti al pomodoro with porcini XO. The kitchen is partly open, so the chef sometimes explains dishes. The dining room is lively with toasts and anniversaries, which fits a special-occasion date.

Go on a date here with Known
1701 Octavia St, San Francisco, CA 94109
Reservations

Through the website's reservations button

Less swiping. More stories.

My friend found her boyfriend on Known and this app feels different from other dating apps. I love the intentional matching and how it feels very personal
RyBallerApp Store review
Such a great user experience. Love the layout of the app and the easy to use guide. I am so excited to get matched up! I was part of the beta and went on a couple great dates and I’m itching to go on more.
Sparklemonkey123App Store review
Love this concept!
BrookielegoApp Store review

Selected five-star App Store reviews of Known. Experiences are individual and are not specific to this city.

A little less planning

We’ll find the person. And the place.

Known gets to know you, makes a considered introduction, and plans the date when you both want to meet.

Apply to Join

Matchmaking, not a table reservation service. Venue selection depends on your match and availability.