Best Dessert Spots for a Date in Williamsburg in New York

Patisserie Tomoko brings Japanese and French pastry traditions together in Williamsburg, led by a chef with experience at Le Bernardin. For a dessert date with a twist, visit Friday through Sunday for a three-course prix fixe dessert tasting, served at the counter exclusively for guests ordering the experience. It's a fun way to turn an afternoon sweet treat into a special date, with each course giving you something new to discover together.

Fortunato Brothers is an old-school Italian bakery in Williamsburg that's been serving the neighborhood since 1976. Located at the corner of Manhattan Avenue and Devoe Street, it offers a taste of Brooklyn's Italian heritage, with pastry cases filled with cannoli, colorful marzipan, cheesecake, and seasonal house-made gelato. For a casual dessert date, we'd recommend ordering a sfogliatella and espresso, then picking up a box of pignoli or rainbow cookies to share later.

Ando Patisserie is a stylish Williamsburg dessert shop just off Graham Avenue, with chrome accents, modern furniture, and a bright, minimalist interior. Opened in fall 2025, the Conselyea Street bakery offers inventive pastries and desserts with Asian-inspired flavors, including black sesame cream crepe rolls, osmanthus oolong Basque lava cakes, and coconut milk panna cotta rolls. For a sweet date, pick out a few desserts to share and pair them with hojicha, matcha, or a jasmine tea latte.

Figo Il Gelato Italiano is an Italian gelateria that makes its gelato with natural ingredients. The owner founded it after decades of experience with Mo Gelato. Specials include a Sicilian brioche gelato, affogato and frappe, and the case also holds cannoli, homemade tiramisu and torta della nonna. Pair a scoop with an affogato or a slice of tiramisu and split them for a dessert built to share.

Martha's Country Bakery has been a family-run bakery and cafe for more than 54 years, and its big space holds plenty of cakes, pies and treats. The menu has more than 10 kinds of cheesecake, plus large cookies and large chewy cookies as their own sections, and coffee and pastries too. We'd split a slice of cheesecake and a chewy cookie, with coffee alongside.

Melissa Johnson owns Yummy Tummy's Kitchen, a small Grand Street bakery, after moving up from baking at home to running a business. She began with cupcakes in 2011, and the shop has been serving sweet treats since 2021. We'd go for the strawberry shortcake cupcake or the Twix cupcake, which is sweet without going overboard. Splitting one of each lets each of you pick a favorite.