The Best Bars for a Date on the Upper West Side in New York
Ten Upper West Side bars, from a speakeasy room behind a big red door to a whiskey bar with a huge scotch list.
The Upper West Side has plenty of options for a drinks date, from cozy wine bars and intimate cocktail lounges to lively neighborhood spots with live music. Whether you're sharing a bottle of wine, picking songs on a jukebox or catching a live performance, these ten bars offer plenty of ways to enjoy a night out together in one of Manhattan's most charming neighborhoods.
Prohibition

Prohibition brings a flapper and speakeasy look to the Upper West Side, and live music every night makes it a fit for a first date. Behind a big red door in back, a cozier speakeasy room sits apart from the supper club space where the live music plays. We recommend the house cocktails at the bar, with Lollipop Lamb Chops or a Pro Pie for Two dessert from the New American menu. Tables on the sidewalk out front give you a quiet step away from the music.
$
The Dead Poet

At The Dead Poet, a literary-themed bar, you can leaf through classic books or put a song on the jukebox. Cocktails named after writers are fun options, such as the Walt Whitman and the Pablo Neruda, a spiced rum sangria. Guinness drinkers can work toward the 100 Pint Club, which engraves a name on a plaque at 100 pints. Arrive early if you want quiet, since the louder late crowd comes later.
$$
The Owl's Tail

The Owl's Tail is a husband-and-wife cocktail parlor where locals settle in as though it were their own living room. Plush velvet seats run along its busy L-shaped bar. Cocktails change seasonally, with featured drinks like the Harvest Mule and Truth Serum. Small plates include a shiitake and brie focaccia and cornmeal biscuits with jalapeño butter.
Walk-ins welcome
$$
Vin Sur Vingt
Brick walls and a tiny room set the scene at Vin Sur Vingt, a wine bar with snacks that suits a first date. The wine program focuses on French bottles and has earned an Award of Excellence. French onion soup is among the dishes on the menu.
Caledonia Bar

Caledonia Bar puts whiskey first, with a huge scotch list and lots of snifters, so it suits a date over a dram. Irish and American whiskeys round out the selection. The bar feels like a fairly calm pub with a deep whiskey stock, and nobody expects a formal tasting ceremony when you drink.
$$
Scarlet Lounge
Step into a red and gold Art Deco room at Scarlet Lounge, the cocktail bar of Sopranos actor Michael Imperioli. Plush fabrics, blush shades and flattering light give the room a bold, sexy feel. Scarlet Lounge is cramped, yet its drinks are imaginative and skillfully mixed, and The White Lotus is the sparkling wine option. Truffled bar bites are available.
Not accepting reservations at this time
$$
The Hamilton

Alexander Hamilton himself, in portrait form, watches over The Hamilton, a room styled after an 18th-century tavern. The theme stays light, with mostly brick walls and a few snacks, which makes for a pleasant little bar. Whiskey is the focus, with a serious list built around American whiskey and shelves of bourbon. It works for a first date or a drink with a light bite.
$$
Vanguard Wine Bar

Vanguard Wine Bar is a top Upper West Side pick for a first date, and it works just as well for drinks with a friend or a coworker. Share a bottle of wine, then add charcuterie or a tartine to the table. Walk in when you're ready, since no reservation is required.
No reservations required
$$
The Dakota Bar
For a cozy drinks date on the Upper West Side, The Dakota Bar offers an intimate setting with low lighting and a striking wine wall. The menu is made for sharing, with small bites like mini empanadas, portobello mushroom caps and shrimp bruschetta, alongside heartier options like thin-crust pizzas, pasta and salads. Pair a cheese board with a bottle of red or white wine for an easy evening together.
$$
Nobody Told Me

For a cocktail date on the Upper West Side, Nobody Told Me serves creative drinks in a charming neighborhood setting. Founded in 2019 by mixologist Nick Pfannerstill and chef Alberto Miranda, the bar keeps its cocktail menu fresh with rotating creations like the pepper jelly julep. Try the Copy of a Copy, made with mezcal, hibiscus, almond and lime, for something a little different to sip together.
Less swiping. More stories.
Known is like a better hinge, it’s a great matchmaking service/dating app.
I really liked how the process felt personal from the very beginning. The phone call was relaxed, easy to talk through, and made it feel like they were genuinely trying to understand what I was looking for instead of just matching based on a profile. It definitely felt more thoughtful than using a typical dating app. I’m excited to see where it goes!
10/10
Selected five-star App Store reviews of Known. Experiences are individual and are not specific to this city.
Something to look forward to
Be known. Before we arrive.
Known is coming to this city. Apply to join and keep an eye out for your introduction.
Apply to JoinMatchmaking, not a table reservation service. Venue selection depends on your match and availability.